Skip to content
Get started

Guide

Publishers Weekly, Booklist, Library Journal, and Kirkus: How Book Review Submissions Actually Work

I never asked which trade outlets received my galley, and by the time I wondered, the windows had closed. Here is who submits where, when, what it costs, and what a submission actually buys.

By Adam Zuckerman · September 13, 2026 · 10 min read

The major book review publications aren't four versions of the same service.

They have different audiences, eligibility rules, lead times, submission systems, and paid options. Some expect the publisher to submit. Some have a separate path for self-published authors. None of the traditional editorial programs promise that a submitted book will be reviewed.

That last point matters. A submission is an opportunity for consideration, not a purchase order for praise.

Here's how it works in practice: the publisher usually submits, months before publication, through each outlet's own system, and the editors decide. This guide is for authors on any publishing path who want to know who submits to Publishers Weekly, Booklist, Library Journal, and Kirkus, when, at what cost, with what odds, and what the self-published route is at each one.

Here's my confession for this guide. I never asked Wiley which of these outlets received the galley for No Loose Ends. I trusted the process, which worked out fine in general, and I only thought to wonder about trade reviews after the prepublication windows had closed. I still don't know what was submitted where. Nothing went wrong. I'd just rather know, and if you're reading this before your book comes out, you can.

Quick comparison

Here is the honest state of this page, last checked September 14, 2026. Most of what follows comes from an outlet's own published guidelines. Booklist is the exception: its current submission guidelines are not publicly readable, so this page gives no lead time for it and neither does the Booklist record in the reviews directory. Where a directory record says a rule is unconfirmed, this guide says so too. These outlets also change their instructions without announcing it, so click through before you submit.

Publication Primary trade audience Who normally submits a traditionally published book? Self-published route Recommended timing Guaranteed?
Publishers Weekly Booksellers, librarians, publishers, and the book trade Traditional publisher or freelance publicist through GalleyTracker Submit through BookLife Adult titles 3 months before the first day of publication month, preferably 4; children's titles at least 4 months No
Booklist Librarians and collection-development professionals Publisher Confirm current independent-title eligibility and process Prepublication, but the current guidelines are not publicly readable, so no lead time is stated here No
Library Journal Public and academic librarians Publisher or authorized submitter Follow current eligibility and submission rules Review copies should generally arrive about 6 months before publication No
Kirkus editorial program Librarians, booksellers, media, and readers Publisher Self-published books use Kirkus Indie, a paid service Digital advance copy (galley) or ebook 4 to 5 months before publication No
Kirkus Indie Readers, marketers, librarians, and booksellers who consult Kirkus Author or publisher purchases the service This is the self-published path Final work; select service speed Review is guaranteed, positive review is not

Why these reviews matter

Reader reviews and professional trade reviews do different jobs.

An Amazon or Goodreads review helps a consumer decide whether to read the book. A trade review is written for a professional audience: librarians, booksellers, educators, publishers, and media. A review from a recognized trade source can land in the databases and systems used for collection development and purchasing.

When I emailed librarians about my book, several told me directly that they rely on reviews when deciding what to buy. That doesn't mean every library requires a trade review, or that every trade review produces sales. It means you should understand the audience before deciding where to spend time and money.

Publishers Weekly

Who submits?

For traditionally published books, the publisher or a freelance publicist submits through GalleyTracker, which is Publishers Weekly's online form for sending in advance copies. Self-published authors submit through BookLife, Publishers Weekly's site for self-published books.

Publishers Weekly specifically warns against submitting through both routes. If the publisher already submitted the title, don't submit it again through BookLife.

When?

For adult books, Publishers Weekly asks for submissions three months, preferably four, before the first day of the publication month. Children's books should be submitted at least four months before publication.

What's required?

A galley is an advance copy of the book, printed or digital, made before publication so reviewers can read it months early. Publishers Weekly's current general requirements include a submission through GalleyTracker, a digital advance copy, two printed advance copies when printed copies exist (with some exceptions by category), complete bibliographic and publicity information (the facts about the book, and who to contact about it), and U.S. distribution.

The advance copy should identify the title, author, price, publisher and imprint, format, expected page count, ISBN, publication date, distribution, and publicity contact.

Does it cost money?

Under current guidance, Publishers Weekly charges $25 for review consideration, with an exemption for publishers holding qualifying site licenses. Self-published authors pay the same consideration fee through BookLife.

Payment doesn't guarantee selection or review.

What happens for a self-published author?

You create a BookLife account and submit the final digital book for Publishers Weekly consideration. BookLife says the consideration process can take roughly six to twelve weeks. If selected, publication of the review may take longer.

BookLife also sells a separate guaranteed paid review called BookLife Reviews. That isn't the same thing as an editorial Publishers Weekly review.

Official sources:

Booklist

Booklist is published by the American Library Association and describes itself as a source of reviews, readers' advisory, and collection-development guidance. ALA says Booklist publishes more than 8,000 recommended-only reviews a year.

Who submits?

The standard route is publisher submission. If you're traditionally published, ask whether the publisher submitted the book and when.

When?

Booklist is a prepublication publication, so a submission has to arrive before the book does. Beyond that I can't give you a number. Booklist's current submission guidelines are not publicly readable: the American Library Association page describes the magazine without stating the rules, and the guidelines page on Booklist Online sits behind an automated-access check. The lead-time figures that circulate online contradict each other, so I'm not going to pick one and let you plan a deadline around it. Ask your publisher when it submits to Booklist, or write to Booklist and ask.

Is a review guaranteed?

No. Booklist selects titles for coverage.

What to ask your publisher

Has [Book Title] been submitted to Booklist for review consideration? If so, could you share the submission date or confirmation for the book's records?

That's the email I should have sent and didn't.

Official starting point:

Library Journal

Library Journal reviews books for public and academic library professionals.

Who submits?

Publishers and authorized submitters use Library Journal's current submission system and provide access to the review copy and complete title information.

When?

Library Journal currently asks for review copies about six months before publication. If that isn't possible, the publisher should follow the outlet's instructions about alerting the editors.

What should be ready?

Final or review-ready title information, publication date, ISBN and format, publisher and imprint, price and page count, description and author information, digital review-copy access in an accepted format or platform, and a publicity contact.

Is a review guaranteed?

No. The book has to be selected.

Official source:

Kirkus Reviews

Kirkus has two routes that people mix up constantly.

Kirkus editorial consideration

Traditional publishers submit eligible books to the editorial program. Kirkus asks for digital advance copies (galleys) or ebooks at least four to five months before publication. The publication lists categories it generally doesn't cover through the traditional program, so the publisher should check the current exclusions.

Hybrid-published titles may qualify when they have national distribution and are submitted by the publisher under Kirkus's rules.

Submission doesn't guarantee review.

Kirkus Indie

Kirkus Indie is a paid review service for independent authors and publishers. Payment guarantees that a review will be written. It doesn't guarantee a favorable one.

You decide whether the finished review is published on the Kirkus website. That's different from a standard editorial review, where the outlet decides whether to review and controls publication.

Official sources:

Other outlets worth knowing

The four above aren't the whole market. Depending on the book, consider:

  • School Library Journal: youth and school-library audiences
  • Foreword Reviews: editorial consideration focused on independent and university presses
  • Choice: academic library audience
  • The Horn Book: children's and young adult books
  • Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books: children's and young adult collection guidance
  • AudioFile: audiobooks
  • Subject-specific professional journals: often the most valuable option for specialized nonfiction
  • Regional publications: local relevance and author connection

A focused review in the exact professional community your book serves can do more than a famous publication with little interest in the subject.

Editorial consideration versus a paid review

Use these labels when you track opportunities:

Model What payment means Who decides whether coverage appears? Can the result be negative?
Editorial consideration Usually no purchase of a review, although an administrative consideration fee may apply Publication Yes
Guaranteed paid review Pays for the review service, not praise Contract and purchaser options determine publication Yes
Reader review platform Usually no payment to the reviewer; platform rules control incentives Individual reader and platform Yes
Media coverage No guarantee of a review or story Editor, producer, or creator Yes

Never describe a paid review as an "editorial selection" if payment guaranteed that the review would be written.

What traditionally published authors should do

  1. Ask which trade outlets will receive the book.
  2. Ask when the submission will happen.
  3. Confirm when digital and printed advance copies (galleys) will be available.
  4. Don't submit independently until you know the publisher's plan.
  5. Record the submission date and route.
  6. Track "submitted," "selected," "reviewed," and "declined" as different states.
  7. Save the published link and approved excerpt if a review appears.
  8. Ask the publisher to add significant reviews to metadata and marketing materials where appropriate.

Items 1 and 2 are the ones I skipped. Do them in the first month, not the last.

What self-published authors should do

  1. Confirm which outlets accept self-published books.
  2. Separate free editorial consideration from guaranteed paid services.
  3. Review eligibility before paying or mailing copies.
  4. Make sure the book and cover are professionally finished.
  5. Confirm distribution and metadata are in place.
  6. Submit early where prepublication timing matters.
  7. Choose paid reviews based on a defined use, not fear of being left out.
  8. Save the result and decide where it will be useful.

Common mistakes

Waiting for the finished hardcover

Several important outlets work from galleys months before publication. Waiting for finished copies can mean missing the window.

Assuming the publisher submitted

Ask and record the answer. Don't duplicate the submission. And don't do what I did, which was fail to ask at all.

Assuming payment buys approval

It doesn't. A paid review can be critical, mixed, or negative.

Treating all reviews as equivalent

The question isn't only "Is it professional?" Ask who reads it, how it's distributed, whether librarians or booksellers use it, and what you plan to do with it.

Using too much copyrighted review text

Save the source link and use only the excerpts you're entitled to reproduce. Ask the publisher or the outlet when licensing is required.

Frequently asked questions

Can an author submit directly to Publishers Weekly?

A traditionally published title should be submitted by the publisher or freelance publicist through GalleyTracker, Publishers Weekly's online submission form. A self-published author uses BookLife. Don't submit the same title through both routes.

How early should a book be sent for professional reviews?

Plan four to six months ahead. Current guidance ranges from roughly three to four months for Publishers Weekly adult titles to about six months for Library Journal. The exact rule depends on the outlet and category.

Does sending a book guarantee a review?

No. Editorial programs decide which books to review. Guaranteed paid services promise a completed review, not a positive result.

Are Amazon and Goodreads reviews professional reviews?

They're reader-review platforms. They matter a great deal to consumers, but they don't replace trade reviews aimed at librarians and booksellers.

Is Kirkus always paid?

No. Kirkus has an editorial submission route for qualifying publisher-submitted books and a separate paid Kirkus Indie service.

Track every submission and result

Use the free Reviews directory to compare current submission rules, or create a free Author Profile and add your book, one payment, to keep the work in one place.

Sources

Last fact-checked September 13, 2026. Submission rules, fees, and deadlines change. The official source controls.